Cary with Joe Rogan on the set of Fear Factor

Cary starred on Fear Factor on February 24th, 2003. Her stunts included climbing up a ladder hanging from a flying helicopter, and riding a mechanical bull to determine the amount of disgusting food she had to eat. She missed staying on the bull for the full time by just one second, longer than any of the other contestants. But the food challenge turned out to be too much for Cary. She couldn't gag down the massive amounts of bull parts and innards in the short amount of time they alloted. So, Cary went home without the money. But she didn't go home with nothing. She had the bruises and pulled muscles to prove it. Who knows, maybe Cary will be the next Survivor!